3. Drawbacks of ineffective training programs
Learning and training for an employee are essential for any
business, employers should consider potential drawbacks that training employees
can have on the company, existing staff, and bottom line. Companies can use
several ways to train employees, such as on-the-job training or classroom
training. Selecting a training method, employers facing the advantages and
disadvantages of training and development.
3.1 Advantages of training employee
3.1.1 Employee turnover rate.
The training has the potential to change the turnover
thoughts and is an important factor that helps in originating the intentions of
turnover (Kyndt et al., 2009). Those employees that are highly committed to the
organization have lower turnover thoughts. Training basically brings an association
between commitment and retention (Abdulkadir et al, 2012) has considered
training as an investment, the organization bears the whole expenditures of
training employees which eventually act as an investor and expect a return in
the form of commitment and retention from employees. Training elevate
commitment and retention rate when employees consider it as an investment and
force them to offer a return to the organization. According to Sahinidis and
Bouris (2007), training is a long term investment in the skills of employees.
Training is not a tool to polish the current skills of employees but to prepare
employees for future impacts from competitive forces. This kind of training boosts
the commitment and employees think that organization is opening doors to our
success. This sense eliminates the thoughts or intentions to quit from
employees' mind and force them to retain. Fheili (2007) has stated that
employee turnover is a major human capital risk for an organization, which
needs to be catered. Organizations that provide training that is specific in
nature applied only to the specific work within the organization that makes the
employee's specialists, not generalists. By doing this Organization limits the
employment opportunities and leads to the development of committed employees
and will eventually affect the retention rate.
3.1.2 Reduce long-term staffing cost
When employees having better training, then the company can
improve productivity and the bottom line. Training new employees, the company
has to pay for more initial training costs. Effective learning and training
allow the employer to lower companies' long-term staffing cost because the
satisfied employees are less to looking for new employments (Gaille, 2016
; Lionbridge, 2014).
3.1.3 Increasing product knowledge
If employees have better product and technology awareness,
productivity could be increased and further to do constructive changes
(Satterfield and Hughes, 2007). Employees share their product knowledge and
experience with others, then performed employees could be in a better position
in the company (Kraiger, 2002). And they would have good job satisfaction.
3.1.4 Working with the team
When employees training together it creates a common goal
and vision. All employees work to a common goal have created relationships that
are necessary for a team to co-exist in a meaningful way. Effective training
programs train an employee to properly do their job, this builds relationship
among the team (Gaille, 2016 ; Lionbridge, 2014).
3.2 Disadvantages of training an employee
3.2.1 Training Cost
Today most of the organizations have built up different
programs for the training and development of their employees. Generally,
companies offered education reimbursement package to their employees so that
they can improve their knowledge and education. It has been found by the
Corporate University that almost 10 percent of employees are entitled to this
benefit (Rosenwald, 2000). It is the most expensive method of developing an employee’s
skills and knowledge in the present situation. As a result, many organizations
conduct in-house training programs for their employees that are more beneficial
and cheap. The training section of the organization attempts to concentrate on
particular job proficiency whereas the corporate department is positive with an
additional strategic approach. Training and development program is a planned
education component and with an exceptional method for sharing the culture of
the organization, which moves from one job skill to understand the workplace
skill, developing leadership, innovative thinking and problem resolving
(Meister, 1998). Employee development programs include a variety of teaching
techniques, schedule, and helping a learning environment that ensures employees
to improve their skills and later apply to their jobs (Gerbamn, 2000).
3.2.2 Compositors take skills
If the organization spends money to train a new employee
and new member resigns to join a competitor, then the organization has spent
money on a competitor. The employee can join any other company with new skills
and techniques. Employees' career development should be established on a bright
career path which employees can easily accept and gave it worth (Nunn, 2000).
3.2.3 Increased Stress
Many organizations offer continuous training to their
employees. Generally, continuous training is a good idea as it keeps employees
up to date on new trends and also keeps them knowledgeable in their particular
area of work. However, companies go overboard by requiring their employees to
complete an unrealistic number of hours of ongoing training. This level of
over-training can become very stressful for employee overtime. And when
employees are stressed, job performance goes down.
Reference
Abdulkadir, D. et al., (2012). Effects of Strategic
Performance Appraisal, Career Planning and Employee Participation on
Organizational Commitment: An Empirical Study. International Business Research,
5(4), 124-133.
Fheili,
M., (2007) Employee
turnover: an HR
risk with firm-specific
context. Journal of Operational Risk, 2(3), 69-84.
Gaille (2016), 10 Pros and Cons of Training
Employees[online] Available at https://brandongaille.com/10-pros-and-cons-of-training-employees/,
[Accessed on 20 September 2018]
Gerbman, R. V. (2000). Corporate Universities 101.
HR Magazine, 45 (2), 101-106.
Kraiger K. (2002). Decision-based Evaluation. In
Creating, Implementing, and Maintaining Effective Training and Development,
State-of-the-Art Lessons for Practice, 1st ed. K Kraiger, pp. 331–75. San
Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass
Kyndt,
E. et al.,
(2009). Employee Retention:
Organizational and Personal Perspectives. Vocations and
Learning, 2, 195-215.
Lionbridge (2014), Top 5 Training and Development
Challenges [online] Available at
http://content.lionbridge.com/top-td-challenges-address/, [Accessed on 20
September 2018]
Meister, J. C. (1998). Ten steps to creating a
corporate university. Training and Development, 52(11), 38-43.
Nunn, J. (2000). Career planning key to employee
retention. Journal of Property Management, 65 (5), 20-21.
Rosenwald, M. (2000) Working class: More companies
are creating corporate universities to help employees sharpen skills and learn
new ones. Boston Globe, H1.
Sahinidis, A. & Bouris, J., (2008) Employee
perceived training effectiveness relationship to employee attitudes. Journal of
European Industrial Training, 32(1), 63-76.
Satterfield JM, Hughes E. (2007). Emotion skills
training for medical students: a systematic review. Medical Education,
41:935–41.
Hi Gayanee, you have clearly explained the effectiveness of learning and training for employees in your blog. However, the organizations do not always offer the right training forms and contents for their employees and the wrong allocation of training contents and training forms can be considered as one of the main causes for the lower effectiveness of training provided to the employees. Especially, training provided for the older employees of an organization is less effective since it appears that the older employees pursue less ambitious goals with their participation in training activities carried out by the organization (Zwick, 2011).
ReplyDeleteDear Gayanee, I totally agreed what you have pointed out on effectiveness in learning and Training for employees, it is true that there can be disadvantages in training were organization will spend lots of resources but the benefit will goes to some were else. This is mainly due to the reason of not analyzing and determining the actual need of leaning and development of the organization. According to Armstrong (2006) by identified the actual need and structuring the leaning and development of the organization and recognizing these employees, empowering them rewording can mitigate these disadvantages.
ReplyDeleteHi Gayanee,
ReplyDeleteInteresting Topic & Valuable content. As you share Learning and training increase the stress level of employee instead of Motivation is very important and valid point. In present working environment this reason can be seen amply and all employers must pay their attention on this. Because Business success is based on many factors and the most important to have competent, skillful and motivated workforce. These skills, competencies, knowledge and motivation can be enhanced through training (Adam, 1963). Therefore training and learning must be designed in order to increase the motivation
Further Swart et al, says organizations are needed to retain human asset by keeping them motivated through effective trainings for further development and to enhance their skills for betterment and success of the company (Swart et al, 2005)